To the editor: Pro-Scott Super-PAC ad skewers truth

Recently, a Political Action Committee has begun investing heavily into Gov. Phil Scott’s campaign for reelection. This super PAC — A Stronger Vermont, which has ties to the national Republican Governors Association — has recently invested over $460,000 into advertising for Scott, according to reports filed with our Vermont’s Secretary of State’s Office.

It was reported that the same organization spent more than $2.8 million to help him get elected governor for the first time in 2016.

The ethics, or lack thereof, of this super PAC’s style of advertising can be debated until the cows come home, but two aspects of this particular ad campaign are hard to ignore: It makes a feeble attempt to cast a negative light on Amanda Janoo with quotes from Democrats – one of them her opponent in the primaries – that were made prior to Janoo becoming the Democratic nominee; and, conversely, it tries to shine a favorable light on Scott with statements that don’t bear up under even a modest amount of scrutiny.

The most boldface of these are that the governor is known to bring people together, and that he works across the aisle. Those assertions may have come as a surprise to even Phil Scott himself, since he has taken to repeatedly blaming the Democratic supermajority – which only existed for two of Scott’s 10-year tenure – for all of Vermont’s current ills, and governing by vetoes and executive orders.

There is a lot of daylight between describing Scott as bipartisan and the reality of his endless finger-pointing and his “My way or the highway” style of governing.

One could rightly point out that the governor — or any politician for that matter — has no control over what PACs put out into the media, but in a recent VTDigger article on the matter, Scott said, “he would prefer to ‘just run our own campaign and do the best we can with giving our own message.’ But he also said he did not have an issue with the ad that featured Janoo. ‘I don’t like the negative campaigning. But I thought it struck the right balance. It seems to be palatable,’ he said.”

So he says he doesn’t like negative campaigning, but is OK with this ad. Hard to square that circle.

Many people, myself included, see the massive amounts of money invested into elections since Citizens United opened those floodgates as an affront, and to use those monies to present blatant falsehoods as fact only serves to rub salt into that wound.

The end of the Stronger Vermont ad characterizes Scott as “Proven. Effective. Bipartisan.” The only thing he has proven to be effective at has been undermining our public education system, and to cast him as bipartisan implies Vermonters – regardless of political affiliation – have been living in caves.

Ken Fredette 
Wallingford

Filed Under: Commentary • Letters to the Editor

About the Author:

RSSComments (1)

Leave a Reply | Trackback URL

  1. Leslie Thorsen says:

    I would like to support Mr. Fredette’s commentary on the Super PAC: A Stronger Vermont. As he so aptly mentioned this is funded by The Republican Governor’s Association, who, in this election cycle received a $10 million dollar donation from non other than Elon Musk. The recent television ad put out by Phil Scott, and funded by the Republican Governor’s Association is Elon Musk in our backyard. AW shucks, Phil, you would rather not mention you are now complicit with Elon Musk. I am pretty certain Elon Musk does not have the working Vermonter’s best interests in mind. I am a working Vermonter, and have been very disappointed that our Governor runs the state like a dictator, through veto power. Our hard working legislators work at a break neck speed all winter long, only to have the power of one man’s pen rule by veto. I agree with Mr. Fredette, Phil Scott has been in Montpelier for 25 years! State senator for 10, Lieutenant governor for 6, and the Governor for 9! He never mentions all the experience he has, because he knows he has failed. Instead he says it is not his fault and blames the legislature. Time for a change, thank you Mr. Fredette for bringing this to our attention. Amanda Janoo has built economy’s internationally for 10 years and has new ideas, and is an economist. In contrast, Phil Scott has no new ideas, and relies on veto’s and executive orders. We know what we have, and I am blaming Phil Scott. This Governor that takes money from Elon Musk should not be running our brave little state. Tell Phil Scott it’s time to go home, our taxes are through the roof, there is no affordable housing, our schools are in jeopardy, and our young people continue to leave the state in droves. As Mr. Fredette notes “my way or the highway” type of leadership is not bipartisan, it does not work across the aisle, there is no negotiation, and our hard working Vermonter’s, can’t continue to live this way. Let’s be brave, vote Amanda Janoo!!!!